Reflections on Losing My Child, Part 1: Of Love and Terror

Distorted photo of speeding ambulance, visual for "Her Dying Time: Emergency" at Third Eve

Today, and every day this week, I think of my daughter. I miss her no less today than I did the day she died. That’s the funny thing about bereavement, isn’t it? No matter how many times you hear, “Time heals all wounds,” you know it’s not true. The loss is always there; we simply build around the void. We carry our lost person and the void they’ve left with us always. We hope to see her again someday.


Olivia was a fragile mystery born with Myelomeningocele and associated multiple handicaps. We adopted her when she was two years old. We were full of love and terror. Though ignorant of such experiences and things beforehand, I learned about hospitals, surgeries, shunts, braces, catheters, wheelchairs, orthotics, and how to lift a child paralyzed from the chest down. I learned that a person is not their body nor their disabilities. I learned a great many things, but most especially I learned how to live with fear, anxiety, terror, hope, and love all at the same time.

Olivia began to experience acute medical emergencies around the end of 1999. They would initially present through an uncharacteristic unresponsive lethargy, for Olivia was a lively, vibrant little girl. The first time she had an emergency, the school sent her to the hospital by ambulance, an unprecedented and shocking event. She was dehydrated, the emergency room doctors said–a puzzle, because she had been eating and drinking normally.

These incidents recurred every few months. I would take her to the E.R., but her vitals would be normal. Healthcare professionals who didn’t know her often mistook her lethargy and unresponsiveness for manifestations of physical and developmental disabilities. In a variety of situations, a wheelchair is as much a social barrier as it is a liberator, for people see the disability first and overlook the person.

“Her vitals are good,” they’d say. “Nothing seems out of the ordinary,” another would reassure.

Just wait ’til you see the blood work, I’d think.

Her blood work would come back and show everything was wrong with our child. The room would erupt with activity and bustle. Up we’d be sent to PICU, where with each admission, veins were more and more difficult to find. Olivia would spend a few days in the PICU, get hydrated, and return home an unsolved mystery.


Olivia had a urologist, a cardiologist, a neurologist, a pediatrician, and an orthopedic surgeon, but none could definitively say what was wrong or how to fix it. She was a riddle, a child who might expire during an emergency, but probably would not. A cluster of symptoms pointed to recurrent dehydration.

Each emergency room visit was a physical ordeal for Olivia, and an emotional one for both of us. Olivia was Black, and I’m white, so each time we went in, the emergency room professionals assumed I was her foster mother, someone paid to care. Hospital workers were initially hostile and rude to me, assuming I was giving Olivia no more care than a crippled, Black foster kid deserved, and was quite possibly the cause of her crisis.

I felt persecuted in the Emergency Department even though, for the most part, the physicians, nurses, and technicians were just doing their jobs. I wanted them to do more than their jobs. I wished every time we were there that just one person would stop a moment, look at my child, and see the fear on her face and mine, too, and extend compassion beyond mere medical care.

They never did, not once.

We went through each ER visit holding hands, Olivia and me. A Bible verse that comforted and sustained me, helping me remain a place of calm, comfort, and certainty for my child was Psalm 31:21, “Blessed be the Lord, for he has shown His marvelous faithfulness to me in a besieged city.”


By the spring of 2000, the joy and spiritedness characteristic of Olivia became retrograde planets in her astral chart. She was fading. Her teachers and close friends noticed and commented. At school, aides attributed her changed behavior to boredom, and even stubbornness, but it seemed to me that as her body wore down, her spirit wore down, too.

About every two months, we’d return to the ER, our daughter would be admitted, and put on IV therapy. She had too much acid in her urine–which is called acidosis–but it wasn’t clear why. Each time she was hospitalized, she was seen by her usual team of hospital affiliated specialists. Each time she’d be released after a few days of treatment and IV therapy.

Repeated ER visits and emergency hospitalizations drained my husband and me, and obviously drained poor Olivia. Events unfolded like tense scenes in a horror film: You never knew where the killer lurked, when they’d lunge, when the victim would die.


Emergency department visits are nothing like living with chronic medical conditions and preparing for scheduled surgeries. Scheduled surgeries are planned in advance. One works out a plan of care so that, even in the midst of bodily suffering, there’s a map to recovery. There’s a compass, a routine to develop, a bag full of Things To Do In A Hospital Room, a schedule of loved ones to stay with the patient, and Visitors.

Fear and anxiety come and go with scheduled hospitalizations, but dwindle as a person recovers. At the Children’s Hospital, children on the mend are taken on wagon rides through the unit and are visited by mimes and clowns, animal rescue people bringing cute little dogs and kittens, and celebrities.

There’s nothing cute or fun in the emergency room.


I stood in the vestibule with Olivia limp in my arms, also helpless, also unable to focus, also stunned. I must have looked incapable of movement, for another woman in scrubs leveled her gaze at me and yawped, “The emergency room is closed. Closed. Their son just died.”

The emergency room is closed. The emergency room is closed. It’s closed,
Her words echoed in my head. I couldn’t make sense of them.
How could the ER be closed? We were having an emergency.
Would Olivia die in this emergency? Would she die right then?
Would she die?

“The emergency room is closed?” I asked with bewilderment.
“It’s closed?”

Yes, Scrubs emphatically shook her head. Yes. Closed.


Later, the hospitalist explained that when a person dies in the ER, everything stops for a time. Parents had seen their child die while his blood still glistened on the emergency room floor. The emergency room stopped for their son that day, for them.

I stopped, too, standing there and looking at the blood, my daughter in my arms.


18 responses to “Reflections on Losing My Child, Part 1: Of Love and Terror”

  1. Tammy Avatar

    Motherhood. This is what you are describing here. This is the part that so many fail to see, that motherhood is doing what you have to do so your child has all she needs for as long as she needs it, and for as many times as it takes to get it for her. And you two share something no one else can, even in her dying. You share that journey.

    And you pain about the ER visits is palpable. And it makes me furious. Furious even more as someone who is contemplating foster parenthood… how could anyone ASSUME that there was no love, even if you were her foster parent? Parent is parent, for however long… oh well, that really isn’t the issue. It is truly a sad that even those who are supposed to help care for us in crisis make assumptions that color the treatment received. I am so sorry that you had to experience that.

    And I am truly sorry for the loss of your daughter… it is a real loss to this world not having her here.

  2. Eve Avatar

    David, what you said. Exactly what you said. There are so many misconceptions about loving and losing a child with a disability. Several friends (yes, friends) remarked that Olivia was “better off” once she died, and that we were, too. Some ‘comforted’ us by saying “at least you still have other children.” Another long-time friend and our own daughter-in-law said that Olivia should have been allowed to die at birth, without thinking that “allowing” her to die would have meant withholding all life-sustaining care, such as baby formula. Such as surgery to close the myelomeningocele. Such as antibiotics to prevent infection.

    My husband and I, and indeed our whole family (minus that cruel-hearted daughter-in-law) felt that, through Olivia’s adoption, we were given the rare opportunity to know and love a person who was a rarity in this world: a person full of joy. I really mean that she was full of joy; she just was. Yes, she had her flaws. But the world was a different place as seen through her eyes: it was glorious. We were and remain grateful for her life.

  3. litlove Avatar

    This is horribly powerful, gut-wrenching even. No, I don’t know how you managed to get through all that, but you clearly did and it must be a tremendous tribute to the love you had for each other and for the rest of your family. I am so sorry for your loss.

  4. crazymumma Avatar

    oh what a song of sorrow.

    I am so sorry for your loss. years ago, but no less.

  5. Lee Avatar
    Lee

    I only wanted to say that nothing you wrote was macabre. To me, it would be macabre to pretend Olivia hadn’t been a vibrant and beloved part of your life. Someone who is missed lives on in our memories and our stories.

    I think losing a child has to be the worst kind of pain. {{{{{{{{{{}}}}}}}}}}}

  6. davidrochester Avatar

    I can’t type today … I meant “overlooked and unseen” in the second sentence.

  7. davidrochester Avatar

    I didn’t find the post to be macabre, either.

    I don’t think there’s a combination of words with sufficient finesse for what I want to say, so I will simply say it awkwardly and hope you know what I mean … it’s a beautiful and joyful thing that you miss Olivia. From what you’ve said, it would have been very easy for her to be overlooked and missed or terribly misunderstood and neglected during her brief time here in the world. But you saw her, you had her, you loved her, despite her frailty and physical challenges. It’s a wonderful thing that she was known, and that she is missed. People who were never beloved and never celebrated aren’t missed.

  8. henitsirk Avatar

    Eve, thank you for sharing about Olivia. I hope it helps a little bit. I don’t think it’s macabre at all.

    I have always been grateful for emergency rooms and the people who work there. Sometimes they don’t live up to our expectations, but thank God for them. Unfortunately they are utilitarian, not nurturing.

  9. renaissanceguy Avatar

    Eve, wow! Words fail. I think that you were able, in this post, to directly transfer your own heart to the heart of the reader. As I wrote, words fail to capture the impact that it made on me. I’m reeling–in a good way.

    I have a love-hate relationship with emergency rooms and hospitals in general. On the one hand, I have found them necessary and even comforting. On the other hand, there have been times when I have found the atmosphere cold and the people indifferent and even rude.

  10. deb Avatar

    She sounds like an old soul. I think I might break apart if something were to happen to Katie. I don’t know if I would be able to survive. She is my heart. I’m sorry Eve. Sending a hug.

  11. Caroline Avatar

    I feel sure, Eve, that Olivia couldn’t have had a more wonderful home than yours; and that she couldn’t have had a more loving mother than you.

    I hope this has given you at least some comfort in the years since Olivia passed away.

  12. newlawmom Avatar
    newlawmom

    Those visits to the ER never leave your mind, do they? Some of the things I saw there are permanantly etched in my memory. Ditto for the PICU. Clowns and child life specialists and artwork painted on the walls. It is the love between parent and child that exists in that space. Love is what makes it so hard. And no matter how much compassion you have for others, it is your own child for whom you fear. I’m grateful to have found you here. So sorry about your loss.

  13. Thankfulpeach Avatar

    Eve ~ I’m so sorry for your loss. I hope you can feel comfort and peace as your remember her today.

  14. helenl Avatar

    Anyone who has lost someone will have to agree: “The loss is always there; we just build wholeness around the void.” You said that beautifully, Eve. I cannot even imagine the pain in losing one’s child.

  15. Helen Avatar

    Reading your post has put a great deal into perspective for me. I feel so selfish every time I have complained about taking Kiko to emergency and thinking: “Why me? Why me?” when we are so lucky to have him. Every child is a gift from God. Your post was not macabre. I think you are amazing.

  16. Eve Avatar

    Thank you guys. I just want to write about this because I feel sad every year at this time (well, every time I think about her, but that’s beside the point), and I haven’t written about this aspect of how I feel. I thought I’d share it. I’m not sure why; just thought I would.

    I hope this isn’t too macabre. But it’s real.

    And thank you, she was really a beautiful child and person. I’ve rarely met someone with as many gifts of personhood (if that’s a word).

  17. Alida Avatar
    Alida

    I sometimes don’t comment when you speak of Olivia, because I can’t imagine my words would make a bit of difference, because a part of me becomes a little frightened. I don’t want to even imagine such a loss.

    After seeing her pictures, and my God, she was beautiful, I feel I must at least tell you that. She was so beautiful.

  18. The Librarian in Purgatory Avatar

    Pain
    And a woman spoke, saying, “Tell us of Pain.”
    And he said:
    Your pain is the breaking of the shell that encloses your understanding.
    Even as the stone of the fruit must break, that its heart may stand in the sun, so must you know pain.
    And could you keep your heart in wonder at the daily miracles of your life, your pain would not seem less wondrous than your joy;
    And you would accept the seasons of your heart, even as you have always accepted the seasons that pass over your fields.
    And you would watch with serenity through the winters of your grief.
    Much of your pain is self-chosen.
    It is the bitter potion by which the physician within you heals your sick self.
    Therefore trust the physician, and drink his remedy in silence and tranquility:
    For his hand, though heavy and hard, is guided by the tender hand of the Unseen,
    And the cup he brings, though it burn your lips, has been fashioned of the clay which the Potter has moistened with His own sacred tears.

    Khalil Gibran, The Prophet

Leave a Reply

Discover more from The Third Eve

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading