In Session, Part 1 : Considering Adoption

Rothenberg's Pattern 1, art for case studies series Considering Adoption at The Third Eve

This article is part of an ongoing series exploring the role of psychotherapy in addressing deep emotional wounds, particularly those rooted in early abandonment. Each installment follows one segment of a single, real-life case study, offering an intimate look at the challenges and breakthroughs that emerge in the course of therapeutic work. Through the unfolding story of Patricia, we witness how past pain can resurface—and begin to heal—when held within a safe and reflective space.



Pearl, The Third Eve

Patricia was a 28-year-old single mother, pregnant with her third child—a pregnancy that resulted from a date rape. Balancing a full-time job while raising two young daughters, she knew that caring for another child would be beyond her means. She had been considering adoption since learning she was pregnant and wanted to explore options that would give her baby the best possible start.

Patricia’s childhood had been difficult. Her father, an auto mechanic, was a violent alcoholic, while her mother—a quiet, passive woman—earned extra money providing home day care. Patricia was the eldest of three children, with a younger sister and brother.

When asked about family relationships, Patricia said, “We girls adored our little brother; we would have done anything for him.” As children, Patricia and her sister created a system to protect him from their father’s violent outbursts: Patricia would draw their father’s anger, while her younger sister took their brother away from the conflict and danger, and their mother stayed fearfully in the background.

One vivid childhood memory stood out—a fierce argument between her parents that ended with her mother locking their drunk father outside the house. In retaliation, he drove his pickup truck straight through their living room window. “That was the last straw,” Patricia said.

“After that, we threw him out for good. By then my sister and I were old enough to make the call, and we told Mom he had to go.” She paused, her hands working at the tissue in her lap. “The three of us raised my baby brother until he could get to college. He was the only one who made it through high school.”

“We don’t see much of him anymore. After college, he married a girl from back east, and now they live their… their nice life away from all this.” The slight hesitation before ‘nice’ carried years of complicated feelings. “But he’s happy. That’s what matters.”

Patricia’s first marriage had unraveled in a way she never anticipated. Her husband, once steady and sober, had inexplicably “turned into a boozer, even though he never drank before, not even at our wedding reception!” The sudden change baffled her, emerging only after their daughters were born. Unable to endure the chaos, she eventually “ran him off, too,” though his irregular child support payments left her constantly struggling to make ends meet. Despite these hardships, she earned an associate’s degree in finance and hoped to secure a better job in a bank or credit union to improve her circumstances.

Determined to break free from the shadow of growing up with an alcoholic parent, Patricia had completed about a year of counseling at a free county clinic before the date rape occurred. She believed she had built a better life for herself and her children than the one she had known, yet she struggled with significant daily anxiety even prior to the assault.

Several weeks after contacting the adoption agency, Patricia learned her unborn baby was a boy. When asked what her feelings were about giving him up, she acknowledged the deepening bond she felt since sensing his movements, but insisted that she needed to do what was best for him.

Patricia explained that considering adoption for her son was a gift, not an abandonment. “This baby needs to be as far away from us as he can,” she said firmly, “so he can have a chance at a better life.” The baby’s biological father was incarcerated on another charge, but likely to be paroled within a few years. Patricia worried about her son’s safety if he remained with her—a realistic concern, given the situation.

The social worker overseeing Patricia’s intake approved her adoption plan and, following standard agency protocol, provided a list of independent local counselors who could offer pre- and post-placement support. She encouraged Patricia to seek ongoing help as she navigated the emotional complexities of the months ahead. Soon after, Patricia began meeting with a therapist—marking the beginning of a deeper journey.

In her report, the social worker concluded that Patricia’s plan was thoughtful, well-considered, and clearly in the best interests of her unborn child.

Everything appeared to be in place.



CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE
This case study is based on real-life therapy work and reflects the emotional and psychological truths of the process. To protect the privacy of those involved, all names and identifying details have been changed.


11 responses to “In Session, Part 1 : Considering Adoption”

  1. Phillip S Phogg Avatar

    I’m writing this from the perspective of not having yet having read your subsequent posts on Patricia.

    Patricia seems to have married the same sort of man her father was – a violent drunk, thus illustrating that, just as men marry their mothers (figuratively, of course!!), so women marry their fathers.

    Patricia’s unborn son will play the same role in her life as did her brother. Both youngest children needing protection from from their violently drunk father, and their being sent away (the baby will be adopted out) is/was the way of protecting them .

    When growing up, Patricia appears to have played the role of “mother” in her family, since her cowering mother was a “child”. Thus was the homeostasis of the family maintained.

    Now, on to Part 2. Already I’m becoming hooked!!

  2. Amyadoptee Avatar

    My first response to this is that she values men more than women.

  3. davidrochester Avatar

    Eve — Ah well, my kick in the gut is easy enough to identify; I wish someone had tried as hard to shield me from my toxic father as Patricia and her sister did for their brother. Then again, if someone had done that, I would probably have taken it as much for granted as he seems to have done.

  4. henitsirk Avatar

    Sounds to me like Patricia has always had to use her “smarts” to stay alive…and now she’s using those smarts to address the issue of a third child. I wonder when her emotions will come into play?

    1. Eve Avatar

      Henitsirk, yes, Patricia’s determination had the effect of keeping her safe–and of keeping her true feelings and self very much underground, and protected.

  5. davidrochester Avatar

    It’s also interesting to me to note how often we hear stories of the handmaiden shielding the prince. One does start to wonder whether myth imitates life, or vice versa.

    1. Eve Avatar

      Ah, interesting comment! I think our lives are myth.

  6. jadepark Avatar

    Amazing. I love that you shared. She is an altruist–and it is interesting to note that that her son and her brother (the two males in her care) are shielded at priority level. This really makes me think.

    1. Eve Avatar

      Yes, it’s startling to see what people will do for those they love–even more than they will do for themselves!

  7. davidrochester Avatar

    For whatever reason, the piece about Patricia’s shielded little brother living his happy life away from his sisters just … kicked me in the gut. I guess it’s nice that he’s happy. I hope on some level he knows what his sisters tried to do for him.

    1. Eve Avatar

      David, we shall see what became of Patricia’s brother. If we were face-to-face or on the phone, I’d ask you about having that gut wrenching experience when reading about him.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from The Third Eve

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading